Why shoot black and white
Without color, a scene is read through tone, contrast, texture and form. Weak compositions stay weak in monochrome, and conversion does not rescue them. Start with a scene that already has tonal contrast and clear shapes.
Scenes that work in monochrome
Storms, fog, snow, harsh midday sun and strong side light all suit black and white. Look for scenes with clear tonal contrast and texture. Weak candidates are scenes whose only interest is color, such as red and green at similar brightness, since those can convert to similar grays.
Shoot RAW in color, convert later
- Preview in monochrome. Set the camera’s picture style to monochrome so you see the black-and-white view on the screen or in the viewfinder. The RAW file still holds the full color data.
- Don’t shoot a monochrome JPEG. It discards the color information you need for a good conversion.
- Convert with a color mix. In Lightroom or Camera Raw, use the black-and-white color mix. In Photoshop, use a Black & White adjustment layer. Plugins such as Silver Efex are also common.
- Don’t simply desaturate. Desaturation gives flat gray. A color mix lets you set the tone of each color.
Filters and color
Physical color filters still matter for film and some digital work. Digitally, the color mix or a channel mixer does the same job. The table shows the usual effects of each filter.
| Filter | Main effect | Approximate exposure factor |
|---|---|---|
| Yellow | Mild darkening of blue sky | About 1 stop |
| Orange | Moderate darkening of blue sky | About 2 stops |
| Red | Strong darkening of blue sky | About 3 stops |
| Green | Lightens foliage and darkens red | Varies by filter |
A polarizer still works in black and white. It darkens the sky and cuts glare on water and leaves.
Exposure and tone
- Expose to the right, without clipping. Check the histogram. Black-and-white work depends on shadow and highlight detail.
- Use the Zone System as a guide. Ansel Adams and Fred Archer developed it around 1939 to 1940. It divides tones into eleven zones, from black (Zone 0) to white (Zone X). Zone V is middle gray, at about 18 percent reflectance.
- Use long exposures for smooth tones. A 6- to 10-stop neutral density filter turns water and clouds into smooth tones.
Infrared
Infrared is another route to a monochrome look, but it needs an infrared filter or a converted camera. A classic 720 nm conversion shows white foliage and dark skies. Filters around 830 to 850 nm give a deeper, darker black and white.
Dodging and burning
Use dodging and burning to guide the eye toward the main subject. Ansel Adams described the negative as the composer’s score and the print as the performance. The same idea applies to the edit: the tones you shape are what the viewer reads.
Common misconceptions
- “Just desaturate.” Desaturation gives flat gray. Use a color mix.
- “Shoot a monochrome JPEG in camera.” You lose the color data needed for conversion.
- “Black and white rescues bad photos.” Weak compositions stay weak.
- “Red filters work on overcast skies.” They mainly darken blue sky, so they do little on a gray overcast.
Related reading
For natural-looking editing across color and monochrome, see realistic landscape photography. For building a strong frame before you convert, see landscape photography composition. For a photographer who taught and wrote about the Zone System, see Minor White’s landscape photography.